Scratchworks Full £29 pack

Guide for UK trades

How to reply to a 3-star or mixed Google review: a UK trades guide

A 3-star review usually means "mostly good, one thing wasn't". That's the easiest review to win back. Here's a simple four-part reply, what to avoid, and eight short examples you can adapt.

Jump to the examples Free 5-reply sample

Why mixed reviews deserve a reply

People reading your profile often trust 3 and 4-star reviews more than a wall of 5-stars, because they feel honest. Your reply sits right underneath. A calm answer that thanks them and owns the issue tells the next customer you listen and fix things.

A four-part reply to a mixed review

Reply within a few days. Keep it to three or four sentences.

1. Thank them first

Start with a genuine thank you. They took the time to write, and most 3-star reviews still contain praise.

2. Name one thing they liked

Repeat back a specific positive, such as the tidy finish or the friendly team. It shows you read it properly, and future customers see the good bit twice.

3. Own the issue in one sentence

Say sorry for the part that fell short, without excuses or a long explanation. You don't need to accept liability for anything you dispute.

4. Say what happens next

Tell them what you've changed, or invite them to get in touch so you can sort it. Then sign off with your name.

What to avoid in a mixed-review reply

  • "But". "Thanks, but..." cancels the thank you. Use "and" or a new sentence.
  • Explaining it away. Long reasons for the delay or the price read as excuses. One sentence of sorry is enough.
  • Asking for a better rating. Don't ask them to bump it to five, and never offer anything in return for changing a review. That breaks Google's rules.
  • Customer details. No addresses, prices, invoices or anything personal about them.
  • Copy-paste replies. The same line under every review looks automated. Mention something specific.

Eight example replies to 3-star and mixed reviews

Swap the [brackets] for real details. Only say what's true for your job.

1. Good work, slow to start

Thanks [Name], glad you're happy with the finished [job]. Sorry it took longer than expected to get started. We're tightening up how we book jobs in so that doesn't happen again. [Your name]

2. Good job, price felt high

Thanks for the review, [Name], and pleased the [job] came out well. Sorry the price felt high. We try to quote clearly up front, so if anything wasn't clear, give me a call on [number] and I'll go through it. [Your name]

3. Great work, left some mess

Thanks [Name], glad you like the [job]. You're right that we should have cleared up better, and sorry about that. If you'd like us to pop back and finish the tidy, email [email]. [Your name]

4. Fine, but communication poor

Thanks for the honest feedback, [Name]. Pleased the work itself was okay. Sorry we weren't better at keeping you updated. We've taken that on board. [Your name]

5. One small snag after the job

Thanks [Name]. Sorry about the [snag]. That's exactly the kind of thing we want to hear about. Please get in touch on [phone or email] and we'll book a time to sort it. [Your name]

6. Okay job, nothing special

Thanks for taking the time to leave a review, [Name]. We'd love to know what would have made it a five next time. If you're happy to share, email me on [email]. [Your name]

7. Liked the team, not the result

Thanks [Name], and glad the team were good to deal with. Sorry the result wasn't quite what you hoped for. I'd like to take a look. Please contact me on [phone] with a couple of photos. [Your name]

8. Short and simple

Thanks for the review, [Name]. Glad parts of it went well, and sorry it wasn't perfect. Please get in touch on [phone or email] if there's anything we can put right. [Your name]

A quick weekly habit

Pick one slot a week, say Friday afternoon, and reply to every new review on your Google Business Profile, mixed ones included. With a calm template ready, most take under a minute.

More help

Free guides for the other review situations.

Reply templates

Eight ready-to-adapt starters for praise, mixed feedback, timing, price and workmanship.

1-star reviews

Five calm steps and eight examples for the worst reviews.

Star-only reviews

What to say when there's a rating but no written comment, at every star level.

Want 50 replies ready to paste, mixed reviews included?

The 50 Google Review Replies for UK Trades pack covers praise, mixed feedback, angry reviews, no-shows and price complaints, plus a one-page note on what never to admit in writing.

£29 once · instant PDF on Gumroad · no subscription · templates only.

Get the Reply Pack (£29) Try 5 free replies first

By trade: Plumber · Electrician · Builder · Roofer · Landscaper

General guidance and templates only. Not legal advice. Google decides what it shows and how profiles rank, so results are not guaranteed: no ranking, lead or income guarantees. Follow Google's review policies: no fake reviews, no paid incentives, no review gating.

Common questions

Should I reply to a 3-star Google review?

Yes. A 3-star review is often from a customer who was mostly happy but had one niggle. A short reply that thanks them for the good parts and owns the issue shows future customers you listen.

How do I reply to a mixed Google review?

Thank them, repeat back one thing they liked, acknowledge the issue in a sentence without arguing, say what you'll do or have done, and invite them to get in touch. Keep it to three or four sentences.

Can I ask the customer to change a 3-star review?

Don't ask in the reply, and never offer a refund, discount or freebie in return for changing or removing a review. That breaks Google's rules. Fix the issue properly and leave the rating to them.

Will replying to mixed reviews improve my Google ranking?

No guarantees. Google decides how profiles rank and what it shows. Replying helps future customers see how you handle feedback. It does not promise higher rankings, more leads or more income.